"I don't get it."
"You're not necessarily supposed to.
"When you truly fall in love it will often be the scariest and most exciting times of your life because you are actually risking everything.'"
"Why would one be afraid of falling in love?"
"Well I'm sure everyone, to one extent or another, has certain fears when they get involved with the person they think might be their one true lifelong love - what if they are the wrong one, what if we aren't a good match, will I stay happy, etc. Doubts and fears are natural, to an extent, but they can easily become debilitating. For example, some people have additionally strong fears, which can be brought on by the divorce of the person's parents, abandonment by a parent (or two), hurt in prior relationships, past abuse, etc. For these people, the stakes seem higher because they're short stacked."
"... I sense a metaphor coming."
"It's often easier for people to play the five dollar tables in gambling - stay with the person that could never possibly leave you, get into fundamentally flawed relationships that are doomed to fail, or something that has the net effect of allowing them to avoid the truly intimate relationship that has the most potential of hurting them. Everyone copes with this fear in their own way - everyone has their own tolerance for risk at the casino. Some can play the low stakes tables for the remainder of their days and find true joy and comfort in such an arrangement. However, they will never have as big of a payout (or as big of a loss) as the person playing at the high stakes no limit table where they bet big and they take they house."
"So dating is equivalent to gambling or a slightly absurd version of Ocean's 11?"
"Well ... it is a numbers game."
"So what about the people that confine themselves to the low stakes tables or the cycles of slightly worse than ideal matches in an attempt to 'play it safe', are they confined to that pattern forever?"
"It's all emotion based. Emotions are inherently irrational and when you have a negative developmental history - abuse, abandonment, low self-esteem, etc. - your emotions will often not lead you to the healthy outcomes that your rational side truly craves. Moreover, your emotional side will play tricks on your rational side and convince it that it really is getting what it wants. Psychotherapy is often the process of figuring out why you do what you do and then applying rationality to emotion and allowing your rational side a more powerful position in the choices you make. However, the person actually has to want to do this, and it's usually very rare to find people willing to put forth the effort to make the change. After all, safe is ... well, safe."
"Even if it doesn't lead to the most fulfilling relationship?"
"Emotion is attracted to what it knows. Hence, if you grew up being abused, you will often be attracted to either others you can abuse or people that will abuse you. The person with an overbearing parent may, in turn, become overbearing to their significant other or children or both. (We are often products of our parents.) The dynamic that is created will be what the person is used to, and so will be felt as familiar and safe. (This all occurs on an unconscious level and the person is usually never aware of what they are doing.) No one ever said emotions made sense."
"That's crazy."
"Yes, I suppose it is. The interesting thing about psychology is that no matter what you think of your actions and your behavior, you are right. The alcoholic that believes their drinking isn't a problem, the person in the hopelessly flawed relationship who sees it as love, the abusive person that sees nothing wrong with the three scars he just left, they are all right. It is rare that anyone can ever tell you what you are doing is wrong because the emotions will defend you against all rationality. This is why the adage exists that 'admission is the first step'. For without it, all you really have are avoidance and denial."